Considering that Help! functions as the Beatles' fifth album and as the soundtrack to their second film -- while filming, they continued to release non-LP singles on a regular basis -- it's not entirely surprising that it still has some of the weariness of Beatles for Sale. Again, they pad the album with covers, but the Bakersfield bounce of "Act Naturally" adds new flavor (along with an ideal showcase for Ringo's amiable vocals) and "Dizzy Miss Lizzy" gives John an opportunity to flex his rock & roll muscle. George is writing again and if his two contributions don't touch Lennon and McCartney's originals, they hold their own against much of their British pop peers. Since Lennon wrote a third more songs than McCartney, it's easy to forgive a pair of minor numbers ("It's Only Love," "Tell Me What You See"), especially since they're overshadowed by four great songs. His Dylan infatuation holds strong, particularly on the plaintive "You've Got to Hide Your Love Away" and the title track, where the brash arrangement disguises Lennon's desperation. Driven by an indelible 12-string guitar, "Ticket to Ride" is another masterpiece and "You're Going to Lose That Girl" is the kind of song McCartney effortlessly tosses off -- which he does with the jaunty "The Night Before" and "Another Girl," two very fine tunes that simply update his melodic signature. He did much better with "I've Just Seen a Face," an irresistible folk-rock gem, and "Yesterday," a simple, beautiful ballad whose arrangement -- an acoustic guitar supported by a string quartet -- and composition suggested much more sophisticated and adventurous musical territory, which the group immediately began exploring with Rubber Soul. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine, All Music Guide
Review of the review: Oh come on! "Dizzy Miss Lizzy" is nothing more than simple fluff and not worth Lennon or the Beatles. It represents their past, not their future. On the other hand, "It's Only Love" is a Lennon classic... simple but like nothing else produced then or since. Of course McCartney's "Yesterday" transcends this album to reach cult status as one of the rock era's all time best efforts. Why? Because that song easily transcends generations... old and young alike. The song's biggest
Help! is a fine album. It's the album released before Rubber Soul, and it sounds exactly like that. Like a lesser version of Rubber Soul, which is not bad at all since Rubber Soul is possibly the Beatles best album. The songwriting is pretty simple and sticks to the subject of love, heartbreak, and women. But the Beatles were able to pull off these sort of songs without making it grow stale and cheesy.