Kicking things off with two of the most bizarre metal cover selections imaginable ("Mr. Sandman" and a lightning-paced, double-kick version of "Surfin' U.S.A."), Forgotten Tales is mixed bag of counter-intuitive tributes and mellowed-out retreads from the Blind Guardian catalog. It might be possible that this lightweight effort is more of a palette cleansing than the halfhearted recording that it appears to be upon first inspection -- considering that this experiment was released just before the incredibly ambitious Nightfall in Middle-Earth and A Night at the Opera. Speaking of Queen titles, "Spread Your Wings" is easily Forgotten Tales' shining moment. Not so surprisingly, the rock & roll treatment of "Barbara Ann/Long Tall Sally" works much better than the metal-ized pop and rock covers mentioned above. The seven Blind Guardian remakes are consistently slow, earnest, and boring, so for those curious about the laid-back Blind Guardian, Forgotten Tales offers more than a little insight into the group's less serious side. Otherwise, there isn't much that will hold the interest of most prog/speed metal fans. [In 2004, Century Media re-released the album with re-recorded version of five songs -- some of them acoustic re-recordings, others orchestral.] ~ Jason Anderson, All Music Guide
Yep the covers are great, but you only wanna buy this album if youre a big Blind Guardian fan (like me lol). Hansi Kursch's voice annoys all my friends and idk why I think BG and Demons & Wizards are two among the best bands ever! \m/>_<\m/
Certainly an... interesting cd. I think Blind Guardian fans should like it (thought it may not be worth purchasing), but if you're not a BG fan then the covers are the only attraction, and they are more novelty than anything else. Personally I really like the Mr. Sandman cover.