Complete with anthemic choruses, spoken word story lines, and plenty of bombastic power metal punctuating every dramatic turn, Nightfall in Middle-Earth is perhaps Blind Guardian's most triumphant effort. After spending ten years and numerous releases building a large following in Europe and Japan, Blind Guardian took on the task of creating this progressive concept record based on J.R.R. Tolkien's fantasy novel The Silmarillion. The story recounts events from the first age of Middle-Earth, Tolkien's parallel world that serves as the mythological backdrop for his classic Lord of the Rings trilogy. The Blind Guardian interpretation features bassist/vocalist Hansi Kürsch's first-person character portrayals and narrations of the medieval quest for truth and glory. It's really quite grandiose. Except for a couple of quick-paced numbers, Blind Guardian favors an operatic prog rock approach on Nightfall in Middle-Earth, suggesting comparisons to Queen, with dense choir-like vocal harmonies set against swirling multi-part guitar lines. Kürsch lacks the technical abilities of metal's most theatrical frontmen, but his conviction and craftiness make up for these limitations as the vocalist stretches and twists his voice to create that rarest of metal attributes, a genuine sonic signature. Plainly, this music is not for everyone. Listeners who can't take the theatricality of Manowar, Hammerfall, or Helloween probably won't be able to stomach Nightfall in Middle-Earth either. However, power metal aficionados and prog fans with a taste for Celtic minstrel counterpoint, shredding guitar solos, thousand-voice marching choruses, and just about everything in between should have more than a passing interest is this hyper-ambitious release. ~ Vincent Jeffries, All Music Guide
I really liked this. Great mix of Metal & Classical music. But I would feel like a complete nerd to be listening to it. I will buy it, and tell no one. Something I must hide, like Caress of Steel. If it is discovered, I will deny it is mine. (LOL)
I was ecstatic when I learned about this album. It illustrates the important parts of The Simarillion perfectly, and opened the door to some sweet new tunes for me. Definitely turned me on to a genre I largely ignored.
This band is several notches above most power metal. Hammerfall and many others are just too cheesy for me, but Blind Guardian, despite the typical sword & sorcery imagery, are a GREAT band. The vocalist is a screamer, but has a genuine 4 octave range ("lacks the technical ability of other metal frontmen" my a**), fantastic heavy drumming, and very interesting & musical (not just fast) guitar solos. I'd recommend the double live CD if you're only going to buy one album.
I could listen to this album over and over and over all day long. It doesn't hurt that I absolutely adored "The Silmarillion " , especially the ages that this CD covers (A little before the first age, to right near the beginning of the third age). It's a pity there isn't a song about the Two Trees ^_^ (it's my favorite section).