In a world where it's the norm to have a one-off collaboration between a producer and a rapper, something special has to happen to prompt a sequel. Of course, "Crazy" was all the prompting needed for Cee-Lo and Danger Mouse to rejuvenate Gnarls Barkley, their collaboration by mail that sparked the brightest and catchiest single since OutKast's "Hey Ya." But fans and critics have to understand that these two were exactly the types to walk away from a follow-up simply for the purpose of a cash-in, which makes that follow-up, The Odd Couple, such a strange proposition -- it's exactly like St. Elsewhere, and fails to reveal a single new thing. All the hallmarks of a follow-up record are here -- similar sounds and themes, for sure, but also a clear lack of innovation, lyrical and production touches that have since become clichés, and more than just a few passages that will prompt a severe case of listener déjà vu. (Of course, many listeners may enjoy that sense of déjà vu.) As before, Danger Mouse's productions are miniature, modernist spaghetti Westerns, very closely detailed whether their major voice is an acoustic guitar or a choir of unholy voices. These are then chained to amped-up beats and beefed-up basslines to create something that sounds both vintage and up to date, all at the same time. Cee-Lo's lyrics and vocals again reveal a lunatic (or seer) who's occasionally more lucid than the sane, an enlightened psychopath wrestling with his demons and revealing the thin line between being crazy and sensible. At times, The Odd Couple is a more beautiful record than its predecessor -- the duo has never put out anything more moving on a musical and emotional level than "Who's Going to Save My Soul," and Danger Mouse's production work outshines St. Elsewhere on one track ("Open Book"). But all too often Cee-Lo relies on the same sort of lyrical cipher as on St. Elsewhere, although none of them are as effective. "I don't understand how I'm so understanding"; "I'm goin' on, and I think they'll have a place for you too"; "I could be a would-be killer" -- these are the ramblings of a madman; they may sound deep and profound late at night, but they're revealed as nonsense with the light of day. ~ John Bush, All Music Guide
I LOVE THIS ALBUM. Gnarls Barkley has so much energy--this is one of the best albums of the year and everyone should own it. Mainstream hip hoppers as well as fans of the underground can both really really appreciate the unforgettable hooks and raw energy and excitement that Gnarls Barkley brings to this AWESOME album.
Glad I'm not alone in strongly disagreeing with this review. The Odd Couple has a totally different "feel" than St. Elsewhere. If the two albums were a relationship - which is a common topic - St. Elsewhere is the "happy getting along" period and The Odd Couple is the "this is going nowhere, breakup" period. It has a much darker and moody atmosphere, with fewer upswings.
I can and will HONESTLY say that Cee-lo is showing his versatility by completing these two projects. But its not very pleasing to listen to at all. My favorite album of all times is Still Standing by Goodie Mob, where he displayed some of the most creative and thought provoking lyrics I've heard ever. Yeah there are some other gr8 ones out there, but this guy has the stuff the hip-hop game NEEDS. So from a true Cee-lo fan C show them the Gift that was given to you cause "This aint it".Jlam1023
i think the odd couple shows so much growth in the music. john bush is a complete idiot to say that it is the exact same album. i think they stayed very true to being gnarls barkley and the sound they invented, but they made a remarkable new album that i like more than the first
totally right, Bush is jaded and cynical. I love both albums as well, and my Gnarls Barkley station has yet to produce anything as beautiful and soul-speaking as the original.
Yeah whoever wrote this review sounds a little biased. I think both this and St. Elsewhere are both great albums. Boo for Pandora for having such biased writers, lemme guess if we had John Bush's way we all be listening to church music. NO MORE BUSH