James McMurtry's written plenty of great songs, but he's never made a great album. His character sketches and stories have always rung true, and he's as perceptive a chronicler of the disaffected and alienated as you'll find, but his limited vocal range and sometimes almost-indifferent delivery have made even his best discs, Too Long in the Wasteland and Where'd You Hide the Body a struggle to get through. Live in Aught-Three isn't a great album, but the live setting lets McMurtry and his backing group, the Heartless Bastards, breathe real rock & roll life into many of these songs for the first time. "Levelland," an account of stasis in the fly-over land, aches with a longing for something, anything, that's more exciting than high-school football games and farms, and "Red Dress" burns with an angry intensity that you'd never have guessed McMurtry had in him. We also get a dose of McMurtry's deadpan humor on a few between-song asides ("I used to think I was an artist. Come to find out I'm a beer salesman") and a hilarious delineation between intellectuals and good ol' boys. In fact, the strongest material here -- and McMurtry's best work overall -- are the ones in which he finds both the humor and the pathos in quirky, nasty characters like the ticked-off heir to the worthless farmland of "60 Acres," or the twisted crew at a family reunion in "Choctaw Bingo." If McMurtry's albums haven't caught your attention before, Live in Aught-Three is a perfect opportunity to reassess him. ~ Eric Schumacher-Rasmussen, All Music Guide
What makes a good reviewer,isn ' t music just a matter of taste and we all have different things we enjoy? Opinions are like a**holes everyone has one.I find him very enjoyable, but that is just MY opinion!
What makes a great CD? Great tunes... tunes you gotta listen to... tunes that sound great and then after listening for months, you find some new meaning in the lyrics. Disks that sound fresh when they return to your player after a few weeks' absence.
Each new CD from James seems to out do the last, and the Live disk captures energy of his performances... yup these live versions are better than the studio versions.
I don't know how the reviewer can say that Live in Aught-Three isn't a great album. I bought it a couple of years ago and it's rarely left my CD changer. It's one of my all time favorite live albums. If you don't have it and like JM, do yourself a huge favor and pick it up. I love all of mcMurty's albums, but the live versions of these songs are better in every case than the studio takes IMO.