Joy: A Holiday Collection may surprise some Jewel fans, since it isn't a warm, intimate acoustic album. Then again, it may not, since it arrives on the heels of the exquisitely produced, unabashedly pop Spirit, which had lush musical backdrops for her folk-pop tunes. Joy is a full-bodied expansion of Spirit, however -- an unashamed classicist Christmas album, featuring all of the usual carols delivered with strings and choirs. Because Jewel has a big, powerful, attractive voice, Joy works, even if it is a little too predictable for its own good -- the closing "Christmas Version" of "Hands" is the only true signal, musically at least, that this is a Jewel number. Surely, this holiday album isn't a major addition to her catalog, but for hardcore fans, it may be a nice stocking stuffer. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine, All Music Guide
Well, Stephen Thomas Earlwine, what do YOU know? I think this is one of the best Christmas albums out there! I certainly never would have listened to this album at all if it hadn't had a lot of TRUE Christmas carols on it and I was very pleasantly surprised. It's beautiful!
This album just solidifies that Jewel is truly a gifted and talented musician. Some might even consider this a cross-over album - one that is usually crossed over the other way, from classical to pop, however she is going from pop to classical. Die-hard classical singers would consider this a weak attempt but let them try and sing pop music as good as she does. Nice job! and Merry Christmas!