The Mars Volta's 2003 debut was a dense, experimental run-on sentence of science fiction and musical exploration. But though it ultimately rewarded patience with stretches of unbuckled rock & roll genius, De-Loused in the Comatorium was also a maze-like and obtuse migraine dealer that made people frustrated and crazy. For 2005's Frances the Mute, Omar Rodriguez-Lopez and Cedric Bixler-Zavala worked principally with their touring band, but "joining the band for selected moments" are strings, horns, electronic programming, pals Flea and John Frusciante, and the coqui frogs of Puerto Rico. There are no song breaks, making the track listing more of an outline. But Mute's printed lyrics are a helpful guide, a map of Mars that's meant to both direct and fascinate. "She was a mink handjob in sarcophagus heels"; "Don't be afraid when all the worms come crawlin out of your head"; "they were scaling through an ice pick of abscess reckoning and when Miranda sang everyone turned away...." -- perhaps the only match for the cerebral weirdness and eventual beauty of Mars Volta's lyrics is their music itself. The roar of Rodriguez-Lopez and Bixler-Zavala's post-hardcore past is fully locked away, replaced by an equally powerful flair for expressive percussion, intricate vocal harmonies, and extended solos for electric guitar (as on the initial part of "Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus"). Sure, there are moments on Mute that reach the grandiose heights of heavy music -- "L'Via l'Viaquez"'s ear-splitting changes will blow back your hair. But the same song is sung half in Spanish, half in English, and its flashes of heaviness fall between stretches of Afro-Cuban rhythm. Other portions of Frances the Mute are murky and distant, like field recordings from the ocean floor, while still others shift drastically between brittle acoustics and a stuttering, guitar-led volatility that threatens to crack open the earth. Its constant shifts mean the record is claustrophobic and even dizzying; it demands perseverance. But it's great when a blast of a trumpet cuts through a gloomy moment, and Bixler-Zavala's vocals are a thread to reality. For example, while his lyrics for "Miranda That Ghost Just Isn't Holy Anymore" and "Widow" are mysterious poems, he sings them with a fervor that's immediately identifiable. That passion is evident throughout Frances the Mute; it's the organic fever that was buried on Comatorium. ~ Johnny Loftus, All Music Guide
When I bought Frances the Mute at Best Buy in '05, they had a special deal where if you bought the CD, you would get a free CD with the 3 track Frances the Mute song. I don't know if other stores did that, but I know it was a promotion that they ran for awhile. I still find it odd that they cut the title song from the album...
Also, the "title track" was never actually on the album-- it was released as a separate single and is meant to be heard before the album. I've done that, and you can really hear how it's meant to seque into Cygnus.
jadkni: And How! Like most music reviewers, etc, they're trying too hard to compartmentalize music rather than really listen to the genius (or schlock) behind it.
I have never heard anything as musically insane and twisted as Miranda and Cassandra. I mean that in the best possible way. And, of course, The Widow and Cygnus will be the Roundabout and Close to the Edge of this decade.
Well, in the year that I've had this album, I've spun it three times, all the way through. Afterwards, I felt ready to ascend this reality. The Mars Volta are the Universe.
How is Fuel, The Used and Seether even close to The Mars Volta?!? Anyone new to avante-garde rock and looking for something similiar would be greatly disappointed. Similar artists would be more like King Crimson, Pink Floyd, Fear of Music and Baroness.