The Songs of Distant Earth blend together two motifs crafted through Mike Oldfield's atmospheric music. (Both outer space and inner space under water) are the themes of this album, but Oldfield's synthesized artistry comes up short during the course of the 17 tracks, mainly because of the intermittent talking and unnecessary vocabulary that quickly becomes irksome and ineffective. About the music, it is usually Mike Oldfield's differentiation of rhythms or styles on a song to song basis that makes his music thought-provoking and fresh. On this album, the same rhythm lurks through half of the songs, with only smidgens of add-on instrumentation to elevate its flow. Absent is the freewheeling percussion pulses, or the onslaught of strings that so often shower his music. Instead, each track seems flat as his keyboard work comes off gray and bland. Even a few sudden bursts of tempo become short lived, as the pace always falls back to its straight-lined origin. Inspired by Arthur C. Clarke, Oldfield tries to capture the wonder and mystery of the stars and the sea through washes of synthesizer, but his attempt at capturing both themes could have benefited from a multitude of other instruments, as his work usually includes. ~ Mike DeGagne, All Music Guide
I disagree with the album commentary from Mike DeGagne. The lack of differentiation of rhythms that you cite make this album cohesive and quite meditative. The voices heard throughout make it sound like a narrative history rather than just a message-therapy session. This is one of the few Pandora commentaries I've read that's almost negative, but I do hear your glimpse of appreciation for the earlier works from Mike Oldfield.
I first heard this song on the echoes evening radio show, many years ago. I immediately purchased it, have enjoyed this album ever since, never tire of it. It's one of my favorite albums in the past 10 years. I feel it is one of the best written and structured albums I have ever heard, each track fits perfectly with the one preceding it. My hat's off to Mike Oldfield, thank you for many years of listening pleasure.
This really is my most favorite piece of music. I can't tell how many cassettes I wore out (as this is how I got it)just laying back and letting it completely consume me. I'm so surprised at this review because I really believe this album is a true work of art!
Strange to read such a negative review for this album.
The article complains about the 'simplicity' and 'repetition' of the sound/rhythm, but personally I think that these properties are in fact 'what does it for me'. E.g. the beauty of the "flow" from track 6 to 7 still surprises me on how well a simple "beep" is able to drag the atmosphere along.
I'll agree track 17 standing out too much; leaving 16 as a great 'closing title' being a musical resume of the preceding tracks.