I love Weezer, but this is definitely my least favorite CD by them. "Troublemaker" is written very poorly and "Pork and Beans" is better, but still sounds like typical run-of-the-mill radio pop. Although I'll admit, I do like "The Greatest Man Who Ever Lived" and think it's a very solid track, my favorite Weezer CD is still the Blue Album.
Well said wadeharrison! The Greatest Man That Ever Lived is a fantastic track. It has so much going on and the fact that they turned the shaker hymn into a song is interesting in and of itself.
I wasn't into Weezer when they first came out (I didn't end up buying the Blue Album till 4 years after it came out), but having listened to all their cds I have to say they have been consistently good, but the Blue is still my favorite. I'm glad they are getting back to their silly roots in the Red one. As for those who debate about Weezer being as big or influential as the Beatles, the mere fact that there is debate indicates that they are not. Like'em or not, the Beatles are THE powerhouse.
I can't believe nobody, including the reviewer, has mentioned "The Greatest Man That Ever Lived (Variations on a Shaker Hymn)" yet. This is by far the best song on this album! I would love to see them play it live. Miss Sweeney is the next best song followed by Dreamin' and The Angel and the One. I can dig Troublemaker and Pork and Beans but I think the rest are kinda weak. No offense to the band but they need to stick to their own instruments and stop shaking it up.
Unpredictable? Re-inventinve? Bich Please! Porkand Beans is the most cookie cutterish crap pop ever - I love Weezer but take their radio singles like that and throw em out - thats the crap that kills me. Beverly Hills was the first time i ever said "man, that sucks" and a few carry over hear. "Dreamin" and "Angel and the one" are by far the best tracks.
Pinkerton, then Blue, then Green. Everything after that sounds like they were trying too hard. This album sounds like they are done trying. With the end of the Green Era, has Weezer returned to its rightful place as the best band currently producing music? Only time will tell. This appears to be a good start.
Do people (fans) always want their favorite groups to keep making the same album over and over? It seems that way. I think the red album is a really good album, the songs are in the weezer stlye but not just retreading the same musical landscape. The songwriting is getting more complex and they are not afraid to try new things. Give the new stuff a chance, you won't be disappointed.
The blue album was just so much better than everything else they made. you could probably put together their best hits from all the albums besides the blue album and it still wouldn't be as good. Its not that their later stuff sucks, it just seems like they had so much more energy on the first album.
oh and ricka- I love weezer but they will NEVER have the same impact as music (and western culture) as The Beatles. Weezer is great but The Beatles are THE greatest.
so far, this album is really good. especially compared to make believe, which i think was their worst album. ive only heard 4 or 5 tracks off of red, but i thoroughly have enjoyed them all. i will be picking this cd up soon, no doubt about that.
This is a terrible album. Weezer will never again be what they were when they made Pinkerton. Any true fan will be disappointed in the lyrical structures and lack of reinvention found on this disc.