"Whitfield Crane, Rocky George, Randy Castillio & Mike Inez" has been added to your list of bookmarked artists
Whitfield Crane, Rocky George, Randy Castillio & Mike Inez
Selected Discography
A cover isn't supposed to be better, it is more to pay homage to the great band that put it together to begin with.
|
||
Master of Puppets sounds like it was recorded by an amateur 80s band. I agree, this song is better left alone.
|
||
liked it, a cover isn't supposed to sound exactly the same. the vocals are different. wouldn't say they suck.it was for a tribute album anyhow. its not like they just said hey , lets cover MoP. Mike Inez was considered for Metallica at one time. anyone that gives the song some balls again is fine by me. GOOD COVER
|
||
SACRILEGE!!! ! ! ! These guys are obviously talented musicians; however there are some songs that should never be attempted by anyone other than the original artist. This is one of those songs. What's next "The New Kids On The Block" trying to do "Stairway To Heaven" or "MatchBox 20" trying to do "Crazy Train"...... . . . . w h e n will the madness stop!
|
||
Well, not bad at all. I like it better than Dream Theaters Master tribute.
|
||
Yeah, I have to agree. Nice cover (and a splendid definition of one by litecar2).
|
||
this is pretty bad a** j. frazier is right ugly kid joe kicked some a**
|
||
Very good cover. Similar to Metallic but with a slightly different spin.
|
||
Well, if you don't care for the singer, listen to metallica... . W h i t f i e l d Crane was awesome in his own right. Anybody remember Ugly Kid Joe? cool thrash band.
|
||
Some misunderstan d a cover tune, it should reflect individualit y while remaining true to the original.I think this did. The guitar solo certainly had tones of Suicidal Tendencies, and that's not bad. Good cover in all, though I agree the vocals could have been better.
|
||
Interesting. I appreciate the efffort but it's just not as good as the original.How e v e r , it was better than the new crap that Metallica plays
|
||
The solo is solid but NOWHERE near the caliber as Kirk. Oh well though, not a bad cover. Just not Metallica!
|
||
Can't touch the original, but I enjoyed this version too. Probably because I like Whitfield Crane and his work in Ugly Kid Joe
|
||
I feel like Lars, and Mark definately hit the notes on a more consistent level of execution... . w h e n i listen to a certain song forever a certain way i start to appreciate the little things from the original "master of puppets" that the tribute or other bands can't replicate.
|
||
"Yes, but so is James, as well as 90% of good metal. Listen to some Motorhead and tell me Lemmy didn't eat gravel for breakfast."
I understand what you are saying, but when you are used to a song in one fashion, and the "tribute" band changes it in such a way as these guys did, it is a little depressing. I wasn't paying attention, and as soon as the song came on, I had to shut it off. |
||
i was listening to 'master of puppets'
and i just didnt like the way the singer sang 'master' because he sounded like a French dude. i just had to skip |
||
remixed instruments are interesting, but more could probably have been done. the vocals unfortunatel y suck however.
|
||
the guitars are the only thing in this cover that i can appreciate, the vocals are causing me to be a little nauseated
|
||
The vocals sound like a cross between Alice Cooper and Hetfield at best. What is this crap? How about something original? Right, it's a tribute... so how come Alice isn't getting any credits?
|
||
"I found the vocal differences a little grating"
Yes, but so is James, as well as 90% of good metal. Listen to some Motorhead and tell me Lemmy didn't eat gravel for breakfast. |
||
C'mon now f**kin Rocky George is one of the baddest a** guitarist to exist in this world HORNS UP! ROCKY!
|
||
Hmm, hadn't heard this one. The lead guitar is the only thing in this that really has any of its own value. It's hard to hear it with clean ears after hearing the original hundreds of times. I found the vocal differences a little grating.
Probably a fun act to see live. |
||
It would still be great if it was their song originally, but Metallica's is so much better.
|
||
seriosly. your and idiot hell no the solos mest up the voice is stupid. it iz not btr and it never will b.
|
||
I thought the song Master of Puppets on this one was better than the original :)
|
||
This cover is actually pretty good and I say that because I've heard other covers that sound like someone taking a massive dump!
|
||
| report abuse |
Portions of content provided by All Music Guide © 2006 All Media Guide, LLC.